Contract Clutter Has a Cost - Written by Adam Baker of Schooly Mitchell
If you can’t easily locate your vendor agreements, it’s hard to stay in control of the relationship, the costs and what happens next.
One of the first questions I ask a nonprofit is pretty simple: Where are your vendor contracts? How easily they can answer tells me a lot about how closely they’re managing their vendors and, more importantly, their costs.
Sometimes the answer is immediate. The agreements are in SharePoint, attached to the vendor record in the accounting system, or kept in a contract folder that a specific employee is responsible for maintaining. (You’re in control.)
Other times, it takes a while. Someone in accounting might have a copy, there may be one in a filing cabinet, or it’s somewhere on the shared drive and someone just needs a little time to track it down. (You’re giving up some control.)
And then there are organizations that don’t have a copy at all, or the only agree
ment they can find is several years old and has since been renewed or amended. They have to go back to the vendor and ask for a current copy. (Now the vendor is in control.)
When clients ask us how long a cost review will take, we usually tell them it depends. One of the things it depends on is how long it takes their team to track down their vendor agreements. In our experience, the longer it takes to track down the agreements, the more likely we are to find appreciable savings opportunities.
Let’s face it, nonprofits never have enough time. If the first step in routinely reviewing an expense is figuring out where the contract is, it’s not going to get reviewed very often. And that’s where costs start to creep.
Three Dates You Need to Know
Most nonprofits know what they’re paying their vendors. What
they don’t always know are three dates that can significantly impact what they’re paying: when the contract term ends, the deadline to give notice if it renews automatically, and when they’ll sit down to review the contract before the notice deadline.
The review date won’t be in the contract. You have to set that yourself. If you don’t, the contract keeps moving along without you, and you’re giving up control. Start with the term end date and work backward. If the contract automatically renews, account for how much notice you have to give. Then give yourself enough time before that to actually review the expense and decide what you want to do. That’s your review date.
If an agreement renews on December 31 and requires 90 days’ notice to stop an automatic renewal, starting your review in November is too late. The contract has already automatically renewed for another term, and you’ve lost your opportunity to control what happens next.
A Good Deal Doesn’t Mean You Should Auto-Renew
So, let’s say you did the review and decided you have a good deal. The pricing is competitive, the vendor is doing a good job and you want to keep them. Great. That still doesn’t mean you should let the contract automatically renew.
A lot of organizations are hesitant to stop an auto-renewal because they don’t want to lose a good deal. In our experience, that rarely happens. Even if you want to stay with the vendor, give the required notice to stop the automatic renewal. It lets the vendor know you’re paying attention to the agreement and the cost.
Then work with the vendor on the next agreement. You may end up with the same pricing and many of the same terms. If they still make sense, great. Don’t just let the old agreement roll into another term.
You May Already Have the System You Need
Getting control of your contracts doesn’t necessarily mean buying contract-management software. A smaller organization may be able to create a central contract library in Microsoft SharePoint. Larger organizations may already use systems such as Sage Intacct, Blackbaud Financial Edge NXT, Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central or Oracle NetSuite. Before buying something new, look at what you already have.
Whatever system you use, keep the agreements current and somewhere your team can easily find them. Then make sure someone owns the responsibility for reviewing them before the important dates come up. For your significant vendor agreements, I’d do that at least once a year. You’re not necessarily looking to change vendors or put services out to bid. You’re checking to make sure what you’re buying still makes sense and so does the cost.
Make It a Goal for 2027
If you’re not sure how well your organization is managing its contracts, try a simple test. Ask someone to pull three different vendor agreements: your telephone contract, your waste contract, and your printer or copier contract.
How long did it take?
If all three are in the same place and easy to pull up, contract clutter probably isn’t what’s causing your costs to creep. If one is in SharePoint, someone thinks accounting has another, and nobody is quite sure where the third one is, you have your answer.
If that’s your organization, make fixing it a goal for 2027. Get the agreements into one place, make sure they’re current and start tracking the dates that determine when you need to act.
If you’re not managing the contract, you’re probably not managing the cost.
